Betty’s Super Bowl Pie Party Menu


Betty’s Super Bowl Pie Party Menu – GAME ON!

Super Bowl 50, Sunday February 7th. Please place your orders by Thursday, 2/4.

9″ Party Sized Pies

$32 each

Grandma Lucy’s Chicken Pie
Our signature chicken pie, with peas, carrots, zucchini and tender chicken breast, herbed parmesan pastry.

Grace’s Mac N’ Cheese Pie
Macaroni, 5 kinds of cheese, baked and in a garlic bread crust.

Foot Long Sasquatch Pies

$24 each

Garlic mashed potatoes, broccoli and smoked cheddar cheese.

Roasted vegetables, pesto sauce and mozzarella cheese.

Italian Stallion
Italian smoked poultry sausage, marinara, roasted chicken breast and mozzarella cheese.

Hunt’s Chili

$15 quart

Our house-made chicken chipotle chili is sure to be a hit!


$5.95 8oz  /  $7.95 16oz

Cucumber Chive Dip

Poppies Onion Dip

Spinachokie Dokie Dip


Empanada Style Appetizers

$39.95 per dozen

BBQ Sauce, Chicken and cheddar cheese.

Eat Your Greens
Spinach, kale, mozzarella, ricotta, parmesan and asiago cheese.


Sweet Pies

9″ Whole Pies $24 – $28

Available in bite sizes – $1.75/each, minimum 12 per flavor.

Apple Crumble
Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie
Mississippi Mud Pie
Berry Crumble
Cherry Lattice
Strawberry Rhubarb Lattice
Key Lime
Banana Cream

Our Menu selection is subject to change daily. Please check with us at the shop for individual menu item availability. Thank you.